Respiratory Trials·org

Topic

Asthma

Inhaled therapy, as-needed ICS/LABA, and the type-2 biologics.

What the evidence shows

Short-acting reliever monotherapy is over. In mild asthma, as-needed budesonide-formoterol cut severe exacerbations by roughly two thirds compared with as-needed terbutaline (SYGMA 1) and matched daily inhaled steroid for exacerbation prevention on a quarter of the steroid dose (SYGMA 2). Be honest about the trade: daily inhaled steroid still gives better day-to-day symptom control. The same anti-inflammatory reliever principle extends to patients on separate maintenance therapy, and to salbutamol rather than formoterol (MANDALA).

Adding to inhaled steroid and LABA, a long-acting muscarinic antagonist gives modest bronchodilation and a 21% reduction in severe exacerbations (PrimoTinA-asthma) — cheap, tolerable, and worth trying before a biologic.

Biologics work, and the interesting question is for whom. Tezepelumab acts upstream at TSLP and halved exacerbations regardless of eosinophil count, including in patients below 300 cells per microlitre (NAVIGATOR) — the group anti-IL-5 agents cannot help. Depemokimab achieved comparable exacerbation reduction with just two injections a year (SWIFT), though as with the other anti-IL-5 drugs quality of life did not follow. Benralizumab given at the time of an acute eosinophilic attack beat prednisolone (ABRA), which is a different idea altogether: treating the exacerbation rather than preventing it.

For the patient no biologic will help — the neutrophilic, non-eosinophilic asthmatic — azithromycin remains one of the few options, reducing exacerbations by 41% and improving quality of life (AMAZES). Screen hearing and the QT interval first, as the trial did.

As-needed ICS/LABA in mild asthma

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
SYGMA 1 2018 Budesonide/formoterol as needed As-needed ICS/formoterol beat reliever alone on symptoms and exacerbations, but lost to daily ICS on symptom control
SYGMA 2 2018 Budesonide/formoterol as needed As-needed ICS/formoterol matched daily ICS for exacerbations on a quarter of the steroid dose

Biologics for severe asthma

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
SWIFT 2024 Depemokimab Two injections a year roughly halved exacerbations in eosinophilic severe asthma
NAVIGATOR 2021 Tezepelumab Tezepelumab halved exacerbations in severe asthma, including in patients with low eosinophils

Adding a LAMA to ICS/LABA

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
PrimoTinA-asthma 2012 Tiotropium Adding tiotropium to ICS/LABA gave modest bronchodilation and 21% fewer severe exacerbations

As-needed ICS with the reliever

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
MANDALA 2022 Albuterol/budesonide as needed Adding budesonide to the albuterol reliever cut severe exacerbations by a quarter

Long-term macrolides

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
AMAZES 2017 Azithromycin Azithromycin cut asthma exacerbations by 41% and improved quality of life, at the cost of diarrhoea

Treating the exacerbation itself

Trial Year Therapy Effect Finding
ABRA 2025 Benralizumab A single dose of benralizumab at the time of an eosinophilic exacerbation beat prednisolone

Key references

Guidelines, standards and reviews for this topic.